Open bus: Difference between revisions

From SNESdev Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (preferring "main CPU" because S-CPU seems to be confusing)
(Makes this page more accurate and detailed. Adds decay time reference.)
Line 1: Line 1:
Where no device is connected to a data bus, the result is known as an '''open bus'''.
When no device responds on a data bus, the result is known as [[open bus]]. This can happen at memory regions where no ROM or other device is mapped, or when reading from a register for which only some bits are driven, leaving the other bits floating.
This can happen at memory regions where no ROM or other device is mapped,
or when reading from various registers for which some bits are open bus.


For the main CPU, the last value read on each data line will be retained, and reading from an open bus will simply repeat that value for its bit.
In general, open bus will retain the last value present on it for some amount of time before it decays, and so reads will return this stale value. The timing and decay behavior are analog effects and can vary. Driving a bit effectively refreshes its decay timer, largely independent of the other bits.
In most cases this is the last byte of the instruction data fetched before the read (often the high byte of the read address),
or for an indirect instruction it might be the high byte of the fetched indirect address.


The two PPU units each retain a separate open bus memory. Like with the main CPU, when a bit reads as "open bus" from either PPU,
== CPU open bus ==
the value read will be a repeat of the last bit read from its bus.
For the CPU bus, the last value driven on each data line will be retained, and reading from open bus will simply repeat each line's value. CPU writes always drive all 8 bits, while CPU reads may drive all, some, or none of the bits. CPU open bus has been found to decay in approximately 2 frames.<ref>[https://forums.nesdev.org/viewtopic.php?p=287063#p287063 Forum post]: lidnariq's open bus test ROM and results</ref> In most cases, the open bus value is the last byte of the instruction data fetched before the read (often the high byte of the read address), or for an indirect instruction it may be the high byte of the fetched indirect address. Note that a cartridge can potentially influence the behavior of CPU open bus, such as maintaining its value indefinitely or forcing undriven bits to 0 or 1.
 
The 5A22 S-CPU chip also has an internal data bus, and it is suspected there are actually separate read and write buses, each only updated by their respective access type. When reading registers internal to the 5A22 (readable registers in the range $4016-$437F), it is suspected the value only exists on the internal read bus, ignoring and separate from any value on the external bus. In this case, any bits that are open bus would return the value from the last read, even if a write occurred in between because that write would not have updated the read bus. The read bus state would also be lost as soon as an external read occurs, overridden by the external bus even if the external bus is open.
 
== PPU open bus ==
The two PPU units each have an internal output bus with open bus behavior. When the CPU reads a readable PPU register, that PPU drives all 8 bits of its output bus onto the CPU bus, but the output bus may itself have open bus bits retaining for some time the last value driven on them. A PPU register with open bus bits means those bits are not driven onto the PPU's output bus, and so the CPU will read the stale or decayed open bus value persisting on those bits. Writes to PPU registers go to the PPU's internal input bus and do not affect the output bus.
* PPU1 read addresses: $2134-$2136, $2138-$213A, $213E
* PPU1 read addresses: $2134-$2136, $2138-$213A, $213E
** Some of PPU1's write-only registers also return PPU1 open bus when read: $21x4-$21x6, $21x8-$21xA (x=0-2)
* PPU2 read addresses: $213B-$213D, $213F
* PPU2 read addresses: $213B-$213D, $213F
PPU1 may also read the open bus value from any of the write-only registers at $21x4-$21x6 or $21x8-$21xA (x=0-2).


== References ==
== References ==
* [https://problemkaputt.de/fullsnes.htm#snesunpredictablethings Fullsnes: SNES Unpredictable Things]
:* [https://problemkaputt.de/fullsnes.htm#snesunpredictablethings Fullsnes: SNES Unpredictable Things]
* [https://www.romhacking.net/community/548/ Anomie's SNES Documents] - ob-wrap.txt
:* [https://www.romhacking.net/community/548/ Anomie's SNES Documents] - ob-wrap.txt
* [https://wiki.superfamicom.org/open-bus Open Bus] - superfamicom.org wiki (Anomie)
:* [https://wiki.superfamicom.org/open-bus Open Bus] - superfamicom.org wiki (Anomie)

Revision as of 16:17, 11 January 2024

When no device responds on a data bus, the result is known as open bus. This can happen at memory regions where no ROM or other device is mapped, or when reading from a register for which only some bits are driven, leaving the other bits floating.

In general, open bus will retain the last value present on it for some amount of time before it decays, and so reads will return this stale value. The timing and decay behavior are analog effects and can vary. Driving a bit effectively refreshes its decay timer, largely independent of the other bits.

CPU open bus

For the CPU bus, the last value driven on each data line will be retained, and reading from open bus will simply repeat each line's value. CPU writes always drive all 8 bits, while CPU reads may drive all, some, or none of the bits. CPU open bus has been found to decay in approximately 2 frames.[1] In most cases, the open bus value is the last byte of the instruction data fetched before the read (often the high byte of the read address), or for an indirect instruction it may be the high byte of the fetched indirect address. Note that a cartridge can potentially influence the behavior of CPU open bus, such as maintaining its value indefinitely or forcing undriven bits to 0 or 1.

The 5A22 S-CPU chip also has an internal data bus, and it is suspected there are actually separate read and write buses, each only updated by their respective access type. When reading registers internal to the 5A22 (readable registers in the range $4016-$437F), it is suspected the value only exists on the internal read bus, ignoring and separate from any value on the external bus. In this case, any bits that are open bus would return the value from the last read, even if a write occurred in between because that write would not have updated the read bus. The read bus state would also be lost as soon as an external read occurs, overridden by the external bus even if the external bus is open.

PPU open bus

The two PPU units each have an internal output bus with open bus behavior. When the CPU reads a readable PPU register, that PPU drives all 8 bits of its output bus onto the CPU bus, but the output bus may itself have open bus bits retaining for some time the last value driven on them. A PPU register with open bus bits means those bits are not driven onto the PPU's output bus, and so the CPU will read the stale or decayed open bus value persisting on those bits. Writes to PPU registers go to the PPU's internal input bus and do not affect the output bus.

  • PPU1 read addresses: $2134-$2136, $2138-$213A, $213E
    • Some of PPU1's write-only registers also return PPU1 open bus when read: $21x4-$21x6, $21x8-$21xA (x=0-2)
  • PPU2 read addresses: $213B-$213D, $213F

References

  1. Forum post: lidnariq's open bus test ROM and results